Adams Equities › Journal › What an NDA can and cannot keep private in a Florida luxury home sale
By Edgar Adams, Founder & Managing Broker · 2026-10-24 · 8 min read
Part of Buying luxury real estate in Orlando
A nondisclosure agreement in a luxury home sale controls one thing: what a buyer, and the people the buyer brings in, may repeat about the property and the seller before the deal is done. It does not touch the deed. When the sale closes, the deed is recorded with the Orange County Comptroller, the documentary stamp tax paid on it is arithmetic on the price, and both sit in a public record anyone can search. Nor can an NDA excuse a seller from the disclosures Florida requires. So the work of a discreet sale has two halves. Everything controllable goes under contract before the first showing. Everything that will become public gets decided in advance, by how title is held, not by a signature. Below is what an NDA covers, the order we run it in, what stays public regardless, and the cases where we advise against using one at all.
Three kinds of information, each with a different owner. The seller's: identity, the fact that the property is available, the reason it is, and anything said about price. The property's: interior photographs, floor plans, security arrangements, staffing, the art and collections inside, and the daily routine of the people who live there. The buyer's: proof of funds, the entity doing the buying, and who stands behind it. At this price a buyer usually has as much to protect as the seller does, so the agreement should be mutual.
What it excludes matters as much. Anything already public sits outside any NDA: the address, the lot, the tax assessment, the last recorded sale. A well-drafted agreement carves those out in plain words, which removes the argument later over what was actually confidential.
The agreement also has to name who the buyer may share with. The attorney, the lender, the inspector, the insurance broker, the title agent and the family office advisers all need to see something. An NDA that stops a buyer from speaking to their own lender does not protect the seller. It kills the deal, and the buyer's advisers end up working around the paper.
Qualification comes before the NDA, and the NDA comes before any information. We do not send an agreement to a name we have not confirmed can close. Our sequence is a broker-to-broker conversation with an agent whose buyer we already know can perform, then proof of funds or a lender letter reviewed on our side, then the NDA signed by the buyer personally, then the information package, then a supervised showing.
The first step needs no signed paper. One-to-one communication between brokers does not count as public marketing under NAR's policy, which is why a quiet sale can begin with a phone call. The buyer signs personally because the principal is the one who controls where the information goes next. An agent's signature covers the agent.
The sequence also does the screening. A buyer who will not sign reasonable terms before seeing a floor plan has told us something about how the transaction will go.
The deed, first. A closing produces a recorded deed, and the Orange County Comptroller lets anyone view and print official records from its website for free. The Orange County Property Appraiser's record for an address lists the owner's name and parcel ID, and its sales tab shows the parcel's sales history with each instrument number linked to the deed on the Comptroller's site. A buyer and seller who signed an NDA are on that record the day the deed is recorded.
The price, second. Florida charges documentary stamp tax on a deed at 70 cents for each $100 of consideration, under section 201.02 of the Florida Statutes, and the Department of Revenue says it is paid to the clerk or recording official when the document is recorded. The tax is a function of the price, so the stamps reveal the price.
| Sale price | Deed documentary stamps |
|---|---|
| $3,000,000 | $21,000 |
| $5,000,000 | $35,000 |
| $10,000,000 | $70,000 |
We run the same arithmetic on a $5M sale in the cost of selling a $5M home. The consequence for a seller is simple. Confidentiality governs the marketing period and the negotiation. After closing, the price and the titleholder are findable. Anything that has to stay unfindable has to be settled in how title is held, and that decision gets made before the contract, not after it.
Names appear on the record as they are titled. A property held by an LLC or by a trustee under a land trust shows that name, not the individual's. Florida's section 689.073 provides that a recorded instrument naming a trustee operates the same way whether or not it refers to the beneficiaries, and that anyone dealing with the trustee has no duty to inquire who the beneficiaries are. Whether to hold title that way is a question for the owner's Florida attorney, not for a broker, and it has to be answered before the property is shown. The buyer's entity is also a counterparty. The title agent will still ask for entity documents and beneficial ownership, as we describe in our title and escrow piece.
There is a second, narrower tool. A person entitled to an exemption under section 119.071 of the Florida Statutes can ask the Comptroller to remove exempt information, a home address for example, from the online record. The Comptroller's own guidance is that party names stay in the index unless the name itself contains a street address, as some trust and LLC names do. The request must be notarized and state its statutory basis. The Property Appraiser handles the same exemption by marking the parcel confidential, so the name shows as an X, the mailing address shows as confidential and no sales history is displayed. Both tools serve a defined group and a defined set of data. Neither is a general privacy switch.
There was a third layer in federal rule. FinCEN's residential real estate rule would have required reports on certain non-financed transfers to entities and trusts. A federal court in the Eastern District of Texas vacated it on March 19, 2026, and reporting persons are not currently required to file. The government has appealed to the Fifth Circuit. A federal court in Florida upheld the rule in February 2026 and that decision is on appeal to the Eleventh Circuit, so the courts disagree and the requirement could return. Reports under that rule go to FinCEN, not into county records, but the practical advice does not change: expect the title agent to ask who is behind any entity, and have the documents ready.
A seller cannot contract out of what the law requires them to say. In Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), the Florida Supreme Court held that a residential seller who knows of facts that materially affect the value of the property, that are not readily observable and that the buyer does not know, must disclose them. Since October 1, 2024, section 689.302 has also required a residential seller to complete and give the buyer a flood disclosure at or before the time the contract is signed, covering flood insurance claims and federal flood assistance received.
Brokers carry their own duties. Under section 475.278, a transaction broker owes limited confidentiality, which bars disclosing a seller's willingness to take less or a party's motivations, and also owes the duty of disclosing all known facts that materially affect the value of residential property. A single agent carries the same disclosure duty.
The NDA is how those facts reach the buyer without reaching the neighbors. A buyer who has signed can receive the roof report, the flood history and the claims record in full, with no one else reading them. That is the argument for putting disclosure behind the agreement, not around it. A seller who uses confidentiality to hold back something the law requires does not have a private sale. That seller has a lawsuit waiting for a closing date.
Rarely at the buyer's signature. The leak is the photographer, the vendor, the house staff, the second agent copied on an email, the showing nobody supervised. A contract names a remedy after the fact. It does not recover the information.
So the controls that matter are operational. Named attendees at every showing, with names confirmed in advance. No photography inside unless the seller approves it in writing. One point of contact on our side. Vendor access in set windows with staff briefed, the same discipline we describe for a $5M inspection, where vendors are briefed on privacy, nothing photographed leaves the property and access runs through a single supervised window.
The agreement's real value is selection and record. A buyer who objects to reasonable terms has told you something before the property has told them anything. And when information does surface, the seller knows exactly who received what and when.
For most sales at this price, before the first showing. An NDA adds friction, and some qualified buyers will not sign for a house they have not seen. If what worries the seller is a public price history rather than an identity, an office exclusive or delayed distribution handles it without a signed document, as we cover in what trophy sellers need from representation and off-market luxury homes in Orlando.
We recommend NDA-first representation in a narrow set of situations. The owner's identity is itself sensitive. The property is recognizable from a description alone. The sale is tied to a business, an estate or a family matter that is not public. Security is a concern. In those cases the loss of buyer reach is a price worth paying, and we put it in the listing agreement so the seller agrees to it knowingly. In every other case, the friction buys nothing, and we say that too.
An NDA protects a sale while it is happening; how title is held and what the recorded deed says decide what the public learns once it closes, and a seller should settle both before anyone is shown the house. If your sale needs to stay quiet, begin a private conversation.
Adams Equities — boutique luxury real estate brokerage in Windermere, FL. Begin a private conversation.