Adams Equities › Journal › Living in Windermere: is it safe, does it flood, and which Windermere is it?
By Alexander Adams, Principal & Market Strategist · 2026-11-09 · 8 min read
Part of Buying luxury real estate in Orlando
In the Town of Windermere, the crime on the police record is mostly burglary and theft, and the flood question comes down to a few inches of lake. The Town's police department reported 14 burglaries and one homicide in 2024. FEMA puts the 100-year flood level for Lake Butler, Lake Down, Lake Tibet and Lake Sheen at the same 100.7 feet, with the 500-year level just six inches higher. Both answers come with a catch most buyers miss. The Town is only about 5% of the parcels with a Windermere address, and the other 95% have a different police agency, a different tax rate and different services.
The Town of Windermere is about 2.2 square miles and about 1,600 parcels. The 34786 ZIP code holds approximately 30,000, by the Town's own count. That makes the Town 5.3% of the parcels with a Windermere mailing address. Isleworth and Keene's Pointe are not in it. Our Windermere versus Winter Park piece covers what that does to the tax bill. This is what it does when you pick up the phone:
| Town of Windermere | Unincorporated, Windermere mailing address | |
|---|---|---|
| Police | Windermere Police Department, which serves only addresses inside the Town limits | Orange County Sheriff's Office |
| Who answers 911 | Winter Garden Police Department | Orange County Sheriff's Office |
| Fire and EMS | City of Ocoee, under contract with the Town | Not covered here |
| Total millage, 2025 roll | 15.2311 to 15.4839 | 16.3894 (Isleworth, Keene's Pointe) |
| Resident perks | Keys to the Town's tennis courts and boat ramps | None |
Sources: the Town's FAQ; Orange County's 911 directory; the Orange Observer on the Town's fire agreement; Orange County Property Appraiser millage.
Before you read any statistic about a Windermere house, look the address up on the Orange County Property Appraiser site and check the Municipality field. If it says "Un-Incorporated," the police figures below are about somebody else's town.
The Windermere Police Department publishes an annual report. The two most recent, for 2023 and 2024, are detailed enough to compare line by line.
| 2023 | 2024 | |
|---|---|---|
| Incident reports | 223 | 208 |
| Arrests | 70 | 15 |
| Criminal investigation cases assigned | 59 | 47 |
| Burglaries | 9, all of vehicles | 14: 9 of homes, 5 of vehicles |
| Thefts | not broken out | 15: 5 fraud or identity, 5 petit or grand, 5 vehicle |
| Death investigations | 3: 2 natural, 1 drowning | 3: 2 natural, 1 homicide |
| Traffic crashes investigated | 60 | 61, none fatal |
The crime an owner in the Town actually runs into is property crime, and in 2024 it moved indoors. Every burglary reported in 2023 was a car. The Chief's 2023 report noted "a brief uptick in burglaries and auto thefts at the end of the year." In 2024, nine of the 14 burglaries were homes. Nine is a small number and one year is not a trend, but it is the first thing we would ask a seller in the Town about.
Don't read the activity numbers as a safety score. Arrests fell from 70 to 15, down 78.6%, and traffic stops fell from 4,578 to 3,269, down 28.6%. Those numbers track what officers did, not what happened to residents. Calls for service went from 5,486 to 8,411, up 53.3%. The 2024 report, though, says its call counts came from the Winter Garden Police Department's communications division, and we can't tell whether both years were counted the same way, so we put no weight on that jump.
The reports also have a hard limit. They give no FBI-style offense counts and no population figure, so they can't support a per-capita crime rate against Winter Park or Dr. Phillips, and we haven't built one. The Chief's 2024 message says the department reaches calls, medical emergencies included, "within three minutes" on average. That is the department's own figure, and it covers about 2.2 square miles.
Our advice to clients: for a house in the Town, ask the department for this year's burglary count, and ask the seller for the alarm and camera history. For Isleworth, Keene's Pointe or any other address outside the Town limits, these reports don't apply. Ask the Orange County Sheriff's Office for the address's call history under Chapter 119, Florida's public records law, and use that before any crime score from a website.
The thirteen lakes of the Butler Chain are joined by 32 navigable canals, so water moves between them and they rise and fall together. FEMA's Orange County Flood Insurance Study, last revised September 24, 2021, shows it. Its Table 5 gives one set of stillwater elevations, in feet NAVD88, for Lakes Butler, Down, Tibet, Sheen, Chase, Blanche, Louise No. 1 and Pocket Lake:
| Annual chance of the flood | Elevation (feet, NAVD88) |
|---|---|
| 10% | 100.1 |
| 2% | 100.5 |
| 1% (the "100-year" flood) | 100.7 |
| 0.2% (the "500-year" flood) | 101.2 |
Lake Butler is 1,600 acres and Lake Chase is 135. Frontage on each is a different asset, but the flood line is identical. The spread is what matters. From the 10% flood to the 0.2% flood the lakes rise 1.1 feet, or 13.2 inches. From the 100-year flood to the 500-year flood they rise 6 inches. Here the difference between a dry floor and a wet one is measured in inches, not feet. Lake Bessie, which is in the Town but not on the chain, sits a tenth of a foot lower at every level: 100.6 feet for the 100-year flood.
The record is consistent with that. A water-level study done for Orange County's Stormwater Management Division in May 2006 found a highest chain level of 101.78 feet, reached in September 1960 and again in October 2004, and gave Lake Sheen a 100-year elevation of 102.1 feet. That study measured in feet above mean sea level without naming a datum, and it predates FEMA's 2021 revision, so its numbers and FEMA's can't be subtracted from each other. On its own terms, the 2004 peak stopped 0.32 feet, about four inches, below the 100-year line.
So for a buyer on the water, the flood question comes down to one measurement: how high the lowest floor, the garage slab and the mechanical equipment sit relative to 100.7 feet. Take a floor at 102.7 feet as an example. It would sit 2.0 feet above the 100-year level and 1.5 feet above the 500-year level. The elevation certificate gives the house's real number, so get it before the inspection period ends. Fill and floor elevations near the lakes are also regulated: the Windermere Water and Navigation Control District's listed duties include setting the "minimum elevation of land filling for residential building purposes." What a low reading does to your insurance, including the $250,000 federal cap on building coverage, is covered in our insurance piece.
Table 5 describes the lakes. It says nothing about rain falling faster than a lot can drain, or a driveway that slopes toward the garage. Those are site conditions. You find them by walking the property after a storm, or by asking the people who have lived there.
Florida now requires the seller to answer in writing. Under section 689.302, Florida Statutes, a seller of residential property must hand over a flood disclosure at or before the signing of the contract. The form opens by warning that homeowners' insurance does not cover flood. It then asks whether the seller knows of flooding that damaged the property during their ownership, whether they filed a flood insurance claim (including with the National Flood Insurance Program), and whether they received flood assistance (including from FEMA). The 2025 amendment, in force since October 1, 2025, widened the first question to cover any flooding that damaged the property, not just flooding that led to a claim.
Clients should know where the statute stops. It sets no deadline other than the contract signing, and it gives a buyer no right to cancel over a late or inaccurate answer. A "no" is only as good as the seller's memory. On top of the form, we ask for the elevation certificate, the seller's insurance claim history on the property and, if the seller bought recently, the disclosure the previous owner gave them.
The case for it is easy to make. The only flood line in Table 5 belongs to the lakes, so a house off the lakes carries no lake flood risk. Give up the frontage and you give up the risk with it.
We don't buy that, for two reasons. First, an inland house isn't free of flood risk. It is free of the lake line and still has the drainage question that no map answers. Second, the lake line is the one flood risk with a published number, so on a lakefront house it is the one you can actually measure. A lakefront house with a documented floor two feet above 100.7 is a better-understood risk than an inland house no one has surveyed. We would rather own a known elevation than an assumed one, so we tell clients to price the frontage and the elevation certificate together. A low reading lowers what we would pay for a lakefront house. It doesn't make the house the wrong purchase. Our ranking of the five gated communities weighs frontage against carrying cost for the same reason.
Less than the name suggests. For addresses inside its limits, the Town handles police, public works, code enforcement and business tax receipts. According to its FAQ, it provides no water or sewer. Homes are on private wells and septic or connected to Orange County Utilities. Waste Pro collects the trash, Duke Energy supplies electricity, and Lake Apopka Natural Gas supplies gas. Building permits go through the Town's office, not the county's.
Fire protection is bought in. The Town contracts with the City of Ocoee, and at its July 2026 budget meeting the agreement went to $1.1 million from $875,000. The Town covers that with a fire assessment, set this year at $1,157,624.45. The Town's own operating millage has held at 3.7425 since 2018.
Docks are their own case: a new dock or a change to an existing one needs a county permit, which our Butler Chain frontage piece walks through. For schools and drive times, start with our Windermere neighborhood page.
Two documents tell you more about safety and flooding in Windermere than any ranking: the Municipality field on the Property Appraiser's record, and the elevation certificate. Get the first before you compare a single statistic, and the second before the inspection period closes. If you want us to pull both for a house you're considering, begin a private conversation.
Adams Equities — boutique luxury real estate brokerage in Windermere, FL. Begin a private conversation.